Acrylic vs. Fiberglass: Which is the Better Choice for Your Bathroom?

When updating a bathroom, homeowners often face the choice between fiberglass and acrylic materials. Both options are popular for various bathroom fixtures, but they have distinct differences. At Atlas Home Improvement, we believe acrylic is the superior option for most bathroom applications. Here’s why we prefer acrylic over fiberglass for our projects.

acrylic bathtub and shower combo in a bathroom

What is Acrylic?

For homeowners seeking a durable and higher-quality material that is an alternative to fiberglass, acrylic is an excellent choice. Acrylic is made from vacuum-formed sheets of acrylic reinforced with fiberglass, creating a sturdy and attractive material designed to last for years.

What is Fiberglass?

Fiberglass is made from layers of woven glass fibers coated with resin. This combination creates a lightweight, affordable, and easily installed material. However, fiberglass is less durable than acrylic, and prone to scratching, cracking, and fading over time. It requires regular maintenance to prevent staining and damage but is popular for its cost-effectiveness.

Comparing Acrylic to Fiberglass for Bathrooms

How Easy is it to Clean?

Acrylic features smooth, non-porous surfaces that resist stains, mold, and mildew, making them easy to clean with just mild soap and water. They are also less likely to scratch and chip, which helps maintain their appearance and cleanliness over time.

In contrast, fiberglass has porous surfaces that trap dirt and grime, making it harder to clean and more prone to scratches and stains. Regular cleaning is essential for fiberglass to prevent buildup and maintain its appearance, but even with diligent care, it may show wear more quickly than acrylic.

Customization Options: Color, Shape, and Size

Acrylic offers a wide range of colors, patterns, and textures, allowing for endless design possibilities. It can match any style preference, from modern to traditional, and include features like built-in storage. This versatility makes acrylic suitable for various bathroom designs, enabling homeowners to create a personalized and aesthetically pleasing space.

Acrylic is also available in various shapes and sizes to fit different bathroom layouts, from small bathrooms to spacious master suites. It can be customized to meet specific needs, such as corner units or built-in shelves.

Fiberglass, on the other hand, has more limited color and design options, providing less flexibility for homeowners. It comes in standard shapes and sizes, which may not fit as seamlessly into unique bathroom layouts. While it offers some customization, the options are not as extensive as those available with acrylic.

Performance and Longevity

Acrylic outperforms fiberglass in terms of durability. It resists wear and tear better, maintaining its appearance over time, while fiberglass tends to fade, crack, and discolor. Acrylic is easier to clean and requires less maintenance to prevent stains and mildew.

Acrylic has a resilient finish that withstands daily use without showing signs of damage. It maintains its smooth and glossy appearance for years, reducing the need for repairs or replacements. Typically, acrylic lasts between 10 to 15 years, making it a long-term investment.

Fiberglass, however, can chip, crack, or discolor over time and often requires more frequent maintenance. On average, fiberglass may last around 5 to 10 years, depending on the level of care and maintenance it receives. While it may be suitable for short-term use or budget-conscious projects, it may not provide the same longevity as acrylic.

Cost vs. Value

Fiberglass is more affordable due to its simpler manufacturing process, making it a cost-effective option for those on a tight budget. However, it is less durable and may require more frequent replacements or repairs, which can add to the long-term cost.

Acrylic, although more expensive initially, offers greater durability and longevity. This makes it a better long-term investment, as it is less likely to need repairs or replacements. The higher upfront cost of acrylic is offset by its extended lifespan and lower maintenance needs, providing better overall value for homeowners.

Which Material Should You Choose?

Whether you want to compare acrylic vs. fiberglass bathtubs or other bathroom features, you can rest assured acrylic will be the better option long term. While fiberglass may be a budget-friendly option for short-term use, acrylic offers superior cleanliness, durability, customization, and long-term value, making it the preferred choice for many homeowners.

To get started with your bathroom remodel, please reach us by calling 734-259-4374 or contact us online today!

July Financing Offer*

*Financing Terms: Subject to credit approval with minimum purchase made at initial appointment. Atlas Home Improvement is neither a broker nor a lender. Financing is provided by third-party lenders unaffiliated with Atlas Home Improvement, under terms and conditions arranged directly between the customer and such lender, all subject to credit requirements and satisfactory completion of finance documents. Interest is billed during the promotional period but is waived if paid in full within the promotional period". 0% APR if Equal payments are made over 36 months. Vacation Voucher- Offer valid on projects in the bath space valued $10,000 or more, Gutters/GH, $5,000 or more, voucher delivered on purchase, install and full payment. Offers expires on 7/31/24. Consult with our design team for more details.



Special Financing Options

  • Schedule a Visit to Our Showroom
    Yes No
  • MM slash DD slash YYYY
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

*Labor Discount Terms: New orders only. Offer not valid on previous sales or estimates and cannot be combined with other offers. Expires on 7/31/24. CBL: 2102182001. . Gift Card Terms: Gift Card rewarded with purchase and when job is installed. Financing Terms: Subject to credit approval. Consult with our design team for more details.

Logo Green

Customer Reviews

BBB Logo
Google Logo
Facebook Logo
Guild Logo
Angi Logo

"WOW! Our gutters look great! Josh And Kamrin arrived right on time and got quickly to work. They were very friendly and didn't mind our 6 year old grandson asking questions. I would recommend Atlas to our friends."

– Kathy S.

Review Image

"I have been impressed with Atlas home improvement they do things the way I would. Kelly was our installer and was unbelievably hard-working very conscientious and even went the extra mile and called in a grizzly Veteran plumber when presented with a problem. We have used Atlas before and will again soon!"

– Tony M.

Review Image

"Just a quick note to thank Atlas Home Improvement for the new Gutter Helmet install we received today . From the sales representative Hunter who answered all our question about the product and the company itself to the office personnel that scheduled and kept us informed about the date and times the install crew would arrive (Brook). Kevin and Rick did a great job installing and cleaning up afterwards . Thank you Rick for calling us the morning of install just to verify that indeed you would be arriving shortly . Undoubtably one of the best companies I have dealt with . Atlas made it so very easy to keep myself Safe and my home secure from gutter water damage ."

– Harold B.

Review Image

"This was our second experience with Atlas. The shower in our last home was truly a primary selling feature. We returned to Atlas because of the quality of the job and the professionalism of the install. We were happy to see the same installers we had at our other house three years ago arrive here today. Chad and Bill did an excellent job. We received the same professionalism and quality we expected. They arrived with all the materials they would need, no hidden surprises, quality materials. They truly live up to everything they promise!"

– Rob R.

Review Image

"Chris and Brandon did a great job on my Kitchen, I love how it looks! Chris had to come back to fix some things and he fixed all of it."

– Linda B.

Review Image

"Recently, Atlas Home Improvement finished the second phase of my bathroom remodel. Matt and Chad were here every morning on time, stated in their morning phone call. They were friendly, efficient, knew their job and the job site was always in order and clean. They even went out of their way to make sure I was aware of all aspects of the job. They were GREAT!!! This is a great company!!! Very clean and considerate while putting in my new shower. Time the sales consultant was wonderful and really listened to what I want and was never pushy or tried to sell me something I didn't want. David did a wonderful job installing my shower. Great product they sell. I recommend this company highly!"

– Donna P.

Review Image

"Dave put in a stair lift for me and I was very, very pleased with the whole experience. He assessed the situation with an eye on my safety and recommended changing the side of the staircase the lift was to be installed on. He did the installation quietly and quickly and without creating any mess. And he made sure I understood how the equipment worked and watched me test ride it. I could not have been more satisfied with the whole process. I would highly recommend Atlas to any senior looking to modify their home so that they can age in place."

– Dorrie R.

Review Image

"We were experiencing temperature problems with our brand new walk-in tub, in that the temperature would not get very hot. After a call to Atlas we were scheduled by the office staff for an appointment within 2 days, which we very much appreciated. Dave arrived on time and immediately diagnosed the problem - and he quickly fixed it. Dave was very professional, pleasant, friendly, and knowledgeable. Our problem has now been fixed! Thank you Atlas for having such a great installation, office, and repair staff."

– Norv S.

Review Image

"We had our shower completely re-done by Dave. It was a custom job that involved replacing a sub floor and some plumbing issues. They were friendly, hard workers, our shower turned out perfect! I strongly recommend Atlas Home Improvement they stand by their work!"

– Sherry G.

Review Image

"Our dealings with Atlas Home Improvement have been nothing but a delight. We had booked them through Home Depot Home Services which had a salesman come out and was easy to deal with and took his time to explain all of the steps to the process. Atlas delivered the exact way they had promised we were in the loop knowing when our materials were ordered when they came in and to finally setting up the appointment. The workmanship was 5 star excellent and we could not have been happier with our new shower enclosure it really made a difference!"

– Sharron R.

Review Image
Atlas Home Improvement, LLC BBB Business Review